★★★★☆
There is something rather impressive about watching a theatre production fall apart so spectacularly, especially when you know that every apparent disaster must have been carefully planned. Mischief’s Christmas Carol Goes Wrong was both magical and thoroughly entertaining. Taking Charles Dickens’s beloved Christmas story and turning it into an evening of theatrical chaos, the production delivers malfunctioning props, questionable artistic decisions and increasingly frustrated performers. I went in expecting a good laugh but came away equally impressed by the creativity and technical precision behind it all.
Written by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, and directed by Matt DiCarlo, the production follows the fictional Cornley Amateur Dramatic Society as they attempt to stage A Christmas Carol. Naturally, very little goes according to plan.
What I particularly admire about Mischief is that the company never seems content to repeat what has worked before. They keep experimenting with different formats, developing new material and finding fresh ways to make audiences laugh. Their ability to continually reinvent the same basic premise is impressive.
Making this kind of elaborate comedy work on a live stage is particularly challenging. Unlike television, where editing, camera angles and multiple takes offer considerable freedom, theatre has to make everything happen in real time, in front of an audience. Mischief embraces these limitations, turning them into opportunities for increasingly inventive physical comedy and technical disasters. Some familiar running jokes remain, including the wonderfully silly “WANG” gag, but there is plenty of new material to enjoy.
For all the elaborate mishaps, however, it is the performers who make the comedy work. Of course, the accidents and technical disasters are funny in themselves, but it is the performers’ reactions that really bring the jokes to life. Their facial expressions, body language, timing and interactions with one another make an enormous difference. What I find particularly impressive is that they are all clearly very talented actors, yet they have to convince us that they are terrible at acting. And they do it remarkably well.
Henry Shields is excellent as Chris Bean, the director who desperately wants everything to go according to plan. His growing frustration is particularly entertaining, especially because he takes himself and his production so seriously. Henry Lewis is equally enjoyable as Robert, bringing plenty of confidence and theatrical ambition to his performance. Jonathan Sayer’s Dennis also gave me some of my favourite moments, particularly when he struggled with words and tried to find increasingly ridiculous ways around them. Sometimes it was not even the dialogue itself that made me laugh but the way he delivered it and how the others reacted.
The rest of the cast, including Matt Cavendish, Allie Dart, Chris Leask and Greg Tannahill, are equally important to the show’s success. There is a great sense of teamwork throughout. Even when one character is the centre of attention, the others are often doing something equally amusing in the background. The timing between them is remarkable, especially considering how much physical comedy is involved. They make everything look spontaneous, although I can only imagine how much rehearsal it takes to achieve that. I remember Sandra (Sasha Frost) talking about how she hopes to receive good reviews so that she can become famous, go to Hollywood and perhaps find herself a glamorous husband. I am not sure whether my review will help her achieve those ambitions, but I would certainly be very happy to see Sasha perform with Mischief again.
Something else I really enjoyed, which deserves a mention, is the design of the theatre programme. Mischief has cleverly extended the idea of a play within a play beyond the stage (once you see the programme, you will know what I mean). I thought this was such a lovely detail, allowing the audience to enjoy the two layers of the production even before the performance begins. There is also a comic about the Mischief team, which makes the programme entertaining in its own right. I do not normally recommend buying theatre programmes, but I genuinely liked this one and think it is worth having.
Of course, the performers would not be able to achieve quite the same effect without the excellent stage design, lighting and costumes. These elements are particularly important in theatre, where everything has to happen live in front of the audience. Libby Todd’s stage design is wonderfully creative, with falling lights, moving furniture and unexpected changes to the set. David Howe’s lighting also plays an important role, and I especially enjoyed the scenes involving Marley’s ghost. There were several moments when I found myself wondering how they had managed to make something happen so quickly and precisely.
The costumes, designed by Roberto Surace, are equally inventive. I particularly liked the Ghost of Christmas Present, whose costume is a joke in itself. The use of puppetry, especially for Tiny Tim, also adds another layer of humour. I appreciated the way the production uses ordinary objects in unexpected ways, often giving the audience just enough information beforehand to understand why something is about to go wrong. It is very clever, and I would rather not reveal too many details because discovering these little surprises is part of the fun.
Although the production is supposedly about Dickens’s story, it is also about Chris Bean and his relationships with the other members of the company. His stubbornness and desire to control everything reminded me of Scrooge himself. I liked how Mischief managed to connect these two stories and bring some of Dickens’ original themes into what otherwise seems like a rather ridiculous comedy. I will not spoil the ending, but I thought this was a particularly clever touch.
Having said all this, I cannot say that every joke made me laugh. Some moments were genuinely hilarious, while others were simply amusing. Interestingly, the audience around me seemed to laugh almost continuously, sometimes at things I did not find particularly funny. I occasionally wondered whether I had missed some British cultural references, or whether everyone was simply enjoying the atmosphere so much that laughter became contagious. Perhaps it was a little of both. Nevertheless, I enjoyed the audience interactions, which made the evening feel more lively and unpredictable.
At the end of the performance, the company also announced that The Comedy About Spies will be coming to Lowry in Salford next summer. It sounds like another entertaining production, and I would certainly be interested in seeing more creativity from Mischief. If you also enjoy Mischief’s particular style of comedy, it might be worth putting in your diary.

